Supercapacitors vs Batteries: Where Each Truly Wins
This interview with John Söderström, Marketing Director at Ligna Energy, explores the role of supercapacitors in energy storage, their differences from conventional batteries and lithium titanate (LTO) cells, and their applications in everyday electronic devices. He also discusses Ligna Energy’s bio-based, ultra-thin supercapacitors, energy harvesting, battery-free device designs, product performance, and the trade-offs involved in developing sustainable energy storage solutions.
1. For someone who has heard the term but never really understood it, what is a supercapacitor, and how is it fundamentally different from a battery?
Supercapacitors are interesting because they are part of almost everyday life. Just last night, I changed a light bulb at home and found two supercapacitors sitting inside it.
Typically, they are small cylindrical components on a circuit board. Often, they act as a backup: if the power to a device is cut, some components need to shut down safely rather than lose power abruptly. Supercapacitors help prevent damage to other components in that situation, and you find them in many types of electronic devices.
To explain the difference simply, I tend to describe a supercapacitor as a sprinter and a battery as a long-distance runner. A supercapacitor can handle rapid charging and discharging, whereas a battery needs more time, both to release the large amounts of energy it can store and to be charged.
There is also a fundamental difference in how they release energy. In a battery, it happens through a chemical reaction. In a supercapacitor, it is electrostatic, with no chemical reaction involved. That’s the quick explanation without going too deep.
2. Supercapacitors are generally perceived to be weaker than batteries. Where does that perception come from? Is it because batteries can be bigger and hold more charge, or is there some other reason?
I’ve worked mostly with supercapacitors in recent years, but we have now started developing batteries too, so I’ve gained a better sense of how the two compare when you are actually trying to sell them. I’ve compared them side by side myself.
When we ask a customer, “What if you removed the battery altogether and used a supercapacitor instead?”, someone used to a battery-based system will naturally compare the two. And, of course, supercapacitors involve a lot of trade-offs when it comes to energy, so in that sense, yes, they are weaker.
But it isn’t really a fair comparison because they do quite different things. Look at it the other way: a battery is quite bad at handling large peak currents. It’s hard to draw a lot of power out of a battery quickly, whereas a supercapacitor is remarkably strong at delivering quick bursts of power.
So it comes down to understanding the fundamentals of each. In certain applications, you can swap a battery for a supercapacitor combined with an energy harvester, but in general, they shouldn’t be compared too much.
3. From a product designer’s point of view, how does an engineer decide whether a device needs a supercapacitor, a battery, or a combination of both?
We market our supercapacitors as a great way to remove batteries altogether, not on their own, but together with an energy harvester. So many engineers come to us wanting to try a new system design without a battery. They may want to comply with legislation, meet a sustainability goal, cut costs, or something else.
The first question they face is whether they can get energy from somewhere other than a battery. In an indoor office space, for example, you can harvest indoor light. Many customers can also harvest radio energy through NFC, from an NFC reader or a phone.
If there’s no ambient energy available, no light and no radio, then you need to start looking at a battery. Even then, the engineer may want to comply with new battery legislation that requires batteries to be removable, so they turn to coin cells. But coin cells are poor at handling peak currents. If the device runs a radio protocol or a sensor that draws higher peak currents than a coin cell can handle, in the past, they might have needed a larger battery.
Now, a coin cell combined with our supercapacitor is a great option: the coin cell slowly charges the supercapacitor, and the supercapacitor handles the peak currents from the radio or sensor.
So you start with the energy source. Is there ambient energy, or do you need a battery? The supercapacitor sits somewhere in the middle. It can add functionality alongside a battery, and when ambient energy is available, there are great ways to get rid of the battery altogether.
4. There’s one battery chemistry I specifically want to bring in here: lithium titanate, or LTO. LTO batteries have a similar set of features. They are a good replacement for coin cells, handle surges well, and can be combined with energy harvesting. So how does one decide between an LTO battery and a Ligna supercapacitor when they don’t want to use a coin cell?
An LTO is a great component in many ways, and we have spoken with several customers who are facing exactly this question.
An LTO has a higher cycle life than many other batteries, maybe around 10,000 or 20,000 cycles. But there are trade-offs compared with a supercapacitor. Many customers tell us they actually want to get rid of lithium altogether, for whatever reason. If that’s the goal, then you need to switch to a supercapacitor.
Charge time can also be an issue. Even though LTOs handle higher C-rates than some other batteries, they still don’t offer the near-instant charge and discharge you get from a supercapacitor, depending on its size. We’ve had those discussions with customers too. Otherwise, LTOs are great components.
They are available in small form factors, but as of today, there are no pouch-format LTOs. So if you want something as thin as our supercapacitors, which are 0.4 millimetres, that could be another reason.
5. Let’s go back to what Ligna actually makes. Your S-Power range has three products. What job is each one built for, and what kinds of devices do they end up in?
We have three products right now, belonging to two families: the smaller LR series and the larger MS series. All three were developed together with customers.
Starting with the smallest, the LR20 is 20 millifarads and was developed for active smart cards that use NFC charging infrastructure. To charge quickly through a trickle of radio energy, you need a very small capacitance. We’ve been able to make the smallest capacitance in a pouch format; there are no other single-cell pouch supercapacitors in this range. It was developed for one of our customers’ active smart cards, specifically a biometric authentication card, not a payment card.
Next is the LR80, a step up to 80 millifarads. It was developed with customers who specifically wanted to pair it with a CR2032 coin cell. Pairing with a coin cell requires low ESR, among other things, so it has been optimised to work best with a coin cell.
Then we step up to our largest component today, the MS1200, which is 1.2 farads. It is optimised for high charge retention and is mainly used in light-harvesting devices, where the supercapacitor works more like an energy store, closer to a battery. For example, an indoor sensor might need an energy buffer of three or four days to keep running in darkness over a weekend.
6. You mentioned energy harvesting and NFC, so let’s unpack the charging side a little more. Do Ligna supercapacitors need a charger, an attachment, or any external device to harvest energy? Or are they soldered into the customer’s application along with other components?
It’s done in a few different ways, depending on the customer. We have quite a lot of knowledge in the energy harvesting field. Many customers come to us after reading up on it or seeing a few examples they want to try. For them, we have reference designs and quick evaluation kits to get them going. The kit is essentially a small, optimised setup with e-peas and an Epishine cell, so they can get started quickly with indoor light harvesting.
In most cases, though, we sell our components as single supercapacitors, and the customer does their own design. They decide which power management IC to use and which indoor light harvester to use. There are several companies in Europe and Asia offering similar solutions, depending on whether you want something flexible or something rigid with a longer lifetime. It depends on the customer’s needs, but we can always share our knowledge of light harvesting.
Otherwise, as you say, the solar cell and other components are integrated onto the PCB, and the customer chooses what goes on it. NFC is similar. We have some knowledge of how to use the antennas and place components on the circuit boards to make them work. But the smart card industry already has a lot of NFC expertise because it is used in other formats. Essentially, they add a power management component that harvests the energy and feeds it into the supercapacitor. We have a little less knowledge in NFC, but our customers are so knowledgeable in that field that we don’t need to teach them.
7. Sustainability is clearly central to Ligna’s identity, but I’m curious how it plays out commercially. How many customers choose you because your products are bio-based, and how many choose you for performance or form factor, with sustainability as a bonus? And apart from sustainability, what sets Ligna apart from other supercapacitor makers?
Looking back over the past five years, I can see a shift in our customers’ priorities. In the first two or three years, sustainability was a door opener. It was a must-have for companies to engage with companies like ours. Of course, once the conversation started, it came down to performance and other factors.
Today, I feel sustainability is less of a door opener. We now attract more attention and interest because of our form factor. There isn’t much competition in thin supercapacitors, so form factor matters more than sustainability today. I don’t know whether sustainability has taken a backseat or whether it has become a hygiene factor, something that simply needs to be there. My perception is that it has taken a more secondary role.
In many of our applications, thinness is a requirement; a smart card, for example, has to be thin. Other applications may not need a thin component, though it can still be an advantage. Other selling points include being made in Europe and Sweden. Many customers want to work with a European component manufacturer.
We are also PFAS-free. That is connected to sustainability, but our competitors tend to use Teflon, which is a PFAS material, and we don’t.
In terms of electrical performance, our smaller supercapacitors have low ESR, so they can easily be paired with a coin cell. The larger cell is more unique: it has the longest charge retention of any pouch supercapacitor on the market. So when paired with a harvester, it does the best job if you want to get rid of batteries altogether.
At the other end of the portfolio, our 20-millifarad cell sits alone in its capacitance range. There are competing products close to it, but they use double cells, which require balancing, and an unbalanced cell can cause the system to fail. Many customers want something small and simple: a single cell, and that’s it.
8. Since you use bio-based materials, does that bring any limitations? Where do your products fall short, technically or commercially, for example, on cost?
On cost, mass-produced supercapacitors are hard to compete with because we are still a scale-up. We hope to get close to them. But among pouch supercapacitors, we are at the cheaper end of the segment. That comes from simple manufacturing: we don’t use several layers, and we make simple components from simple, sustainable materials.
The trade-off is that we can’t go to the extremes on the application side, for example, in terms of operating environments. Some other supercapacitors can handle extreme heat. We have adapted our smaller supercapacitors to minus 40 degrees, but the larger one can only handle minus 20 to plus 60 degrees, so it is optimised for indoor use. We aim for less extreme use cases: no EVs, no automotive, no space industry. That is one of the trade-offs of working with sustainable materials and less complex manufacturing methods.
Another trade-off is the pouch format itself. It is harder to encapsulate a pouch cell so that it lasts, say, 20 years. We haven’t yet finalised our long-term endurance tests, but we try not to go beyond eight or ten years for some of our applications because a pouch is, by design, harder to encapsulate than, for example, a cylindrical cell.
9. One device you wish would ditch its battery tomorrow?
Electronic shelf labels. Every time I walk into a convenience store or a supermarket, I see thousands of shelf labels. I know how many coin cells are in them and how much they could gain from getting rid of those batteries. And it’s possible.
10. Supercapacitors in 2035: niche component or everywhere?
I can see a future where supercapacitors, especially thin ones, fit together with a coin cell in a coin cell holder. The supercapacitor would last for ten years, while the coin cell is swapped every year or two. If that happens more widely, supercapacitors will become an everyday component.
11. Solid-state batteries: overhyped or underhyped?
Personally, I think they are overhyped in terms of the timeline. Just look across the border at Finland and what happened to one of the companies claiming to have a solid-state solution. I hope we can take a more mature view of how quickly we’ll progress. So the overhype is about how fast we’ll get there, but I hope it happens soon.
Also Read: Beyond Averages: Getting Battery Sizing Right
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Subscribe today for free and stay on top of latest developments in Cleantech domain.
